Gabby Kicks One Guy Out

“Fantasy Suites” week went very differently for Rachel Recchia and Gabby Windey on Monday night’s episode

And in week 9, it was time for both to decide if they would spend intimate time behind

As the episode began, Rachel and Gabby discussed how their previous The Bachelor season with Clayton Echard

Both had three men left vying for their hearts, and Gabby said they had to figure out

Gabby was afraid to take the leap off a higher platform but finally they jumped together

She thanked Erich for being on the show as his dad battled cancer

“My family is obsessed with you,” he told Gabby as they had met her during the previous

She confided in Erich that her parents had split up when she was young and her mom

He added, “I love you, Gabby, and I don’t want to leave here without you

They received a card from host Jesse Palmer with a key to the fantasy suite and they

The morning after, Erich told the cameras that they’d had an incredible night

But knowing her other guys Johnny and Jason were still in the picture was “incredibly painful,” he

“I certainly don’t need to sleep with anyone else,” Tino said

“I am falling in love with you,” Rachel told the sales executive

When their fantasy suite card and key arrived, Aven said, “Let’s do it

The morning after, the two were shown in bed kissing and then Rachel giggled in confessional, “Aven

They jumped off the cliff to swim and Rachel complained about how his parents didn’t like

The general contractor said she was his future and his mom and dad were “going to have

The hunky Florida realtor, always a dark horse for Gabby’s heart, enjoyed a romantic boat ride

They shared a picnic on a Mexican beach and Johnny told her, “I’m so into you

Gabby walked away from him to fume to the cameras, “He’s not able to commit

“So is this our goodbye?” he asked Gabby, who replied, “I think so

Another Gabby suitor, Jason, admitted to Jesse that he also wasn’t ready to get engaged to

But Erich had more ardor, leaving a note for Gabby to meet him on a bridge at

Gabby revealed in confessional that Erich had told her in their fantasy suite that he felt like “

There was clearly more drama ahead—and part two of the fantasy suites episode airs on Tuesday!